Elizabeth II throwing cash at poor kids? Watch out for this intox utilizing a movie shot in 1899

Elizabeth II throwing cash at poor kids? Watch out for this intox utilizing a movie shot in 1899

Printed on :

Because the announcement of the dying of Elizabeth II, Web customers have shared a video displaying two girls throwing cash at kids. In accordance with these accounts, certainly one of these girls is meant to be the queen, in an “African” colony of the previous British Empire. However these photos don’t have anything to do with Elizabeth II. They have been filmed in Vietnam in 1899, twenty-seven years earlier than his delivery.

Verification in a nutshell

  • Since information broke of Elizabeth II’s dying, Twitter accounts have been sharing a video purporting to indicate the Queen throwing cash at “African kids”. These accounts see it as proof that the queen maintained racist clichés and practices linked to the colonial interval.
  • This video truly has nothing to do with Elizabeth II. This can be a movie launched by the Compagnie des frères Lumière and shot in Indochina between 1899 and 1900. The lady within the photos is Blanche Doumer, spouse of Paul Doumer, who might be President of the French Republic from 1931 to 1932 .

The main points of the test

Simply hours after information broke of Elizabeth II’s dying, a number of English-speaking Twitter accounts, together with Kenyan and Indian ones, shared a video purporting to indicate the Queen “throwing meals at African kids”. These photos, which have already accrued greater than 100,000 views, are used to criticize the one who reigned over the UK from 1953 to 2022, but in addition for just a few years over a number of different international locations resembling Kenya, which didn’t achieve entry to independence solely in 1963.

Screenshot of one of the tweets, posted on September 9, 2022, sharing a video claiming to show Elizabeth II.
Screenshot of one of many tweets, posted on September 9, 2022, sharing a video claiming to indicate Elizabeth II. © Observers

A reverse picture search (see right here learn how to do it) can discover a number of publications sharing the identical video, however with a distinct caption. For instance, a YouTube channel revealed this video on Might 21, 2019 indicating that it could actually be a movie shot in Indochina, a federation of a colony and French protectorates, by the Lumière brothers.

A search utilizing the key phrases “Lumière Indochine brothers” confirms the precise origin of this movie. Particularly, it’s listed on the “Catalogue Lumière” website, a Swiss college challenge which lists all of the movies revealed by the Compagnie Lumière between 1895 and 1905.

Screenshots taken on September 9, 2022 on the site "Lighting Catalog".
Screenshots taken on September 9, 2022 on the “Catalogue Lumière” web site. © Observers

And as its caption signifies, this movie has nothing to do with Elizabeth II. It was truly filmed in Vietnam, which was then nonetheless a part of French Indochina, between 1899 and 1900, lengthy earlier than the queen was born. These photos, which have been captured by operator Gabriel Veyre, present Blanche Doumer – spouse of politician Paul Doumer, who would turn out to be President of the French Republic from 1931 to 1932 – accompanied by certainly one of her daughters and throwing cash cash to Vietnamese kids.

You need to submit a photograph or video to us for verification ? Contact us by message on the Twitter account @InfoIntoxF24 !



#Elizabeth #throwing #cash #poor #kids #Beware #intox #movie #shot